Directed by Daniel Sullivan, Sight Unseen opened on May 25 to mixed reviews. In his Broadway.com Review of the show, Eric Grode wrote: "Shenkman may be a tad young for Jonathan, but his gawky body language and tremulous voice are ideally suited to this gifted man-child. And Linney brings all her technical skill and emotional transparency to Patricia, a wounded character that could easily become the lead male's therapist. By now, it's practically a given that Sullivan will elicit every last ounce of pathos and humor from his actors, and he doesn't disappoint."