The production opened on October 10 to mostly positive reviews. In his Broadway.com Review of the play, Edward Karam wrote: "Neal Bell's new 90-minute play is a gem about loss, despair, and the way a death can cripple survivors and permanently scar their lives. It's deeply sad, suffused with sympathy and cleverly ironic in its subtitle: How I Got Away With It. Director Michael Greif's marvelous production ratchets up the tension by degrees yet keeps the pace crisp, while Mark Wendland's mobile gray walls and spare furnishings, and Kevin Adams's startling noirish lighting enhance the disturbing journey. It's one that you shouldn't miss."