
Oh, Father! During the 2004 run of Doubt at Manhattan Theatre Club. When the show moved to Broadway, so did the duo's chapel of love.
Limited engagement.
It's an open secret on the Big Street that O'Byrne has a way with the leading ladies, but his off stage romance with co-star Goldenhersh went beyond showmance winkie-wink to something close to shocking! "He, playing a priest? And she, a nun? Holy %*^#!" Once their runs concluded at the Walter Kerr this winter, sources say, their affair had all but kicked the habit.

