Here is a sampling of what they had to say:
Ron Lasko in his Broadway.com Review: "[The] first two pieces are quite wonderful. Mort and Bev have been carefully crafted with tons of wit and charm. Their problems aren't out of the ordinary, but the ways in which they handle them certainly are… Unfortunately, Family Secrets takes a bit of a downward turn beginning with the third monologue… As an actress, Glaser is quite versatile. She effortlessly inhabits each character… In the final analysis, Family Secrets is good old-fashioned solo show. It might not win any awards, but it certainly is a crowd pleaser. It's just the kind of show you can take the whole family to see."
Jason Zinoman of The New York Times: "The musty material isn't dated because the borscht belt jokes seemed ancient to begin with. What's a dentist's favorite song? 'Fillings, nothing more than fillings.' The reason to see Ms. Glaser is not novelty. It's the pleasure of watching a skilled performer doing something with the meticulousness that only a lifetime of observation and years of work can produce."