Pitcher starred as Christine on the national tour and is currently the New York company's Christine alternate playing several performances a week. Her other theatrical credits include mountings of Sweeney Todd, Hansel and Gretel and The Elixir of Love. She is also an alumna of the Pittsburgh Opera Center at Duquesne, where she performed Papagena in The Magic Flute and Mary Warren in The Crucible.
Wills is no stranger to the role of Christine—she portrayed the damsel in regional mountings of the Maury Yeston/Arthur Kopit Phantom. The actress is best known for playing Eileen opposite Brooke Shields' Ruth Sherwood in the Broadway revival of Wonderful Town. She has also appeared on the Great White Way in Beauty and the Beast and The Woman in White. Wills' other theatrical credits include roles in regional mountings of The Secret Garden, Jekyll & Hyde, Noises Off and the 2003 Paper Mill Playhouse production of Grease!.