Watch Peter Pan Live!'s Allison Williams Talk Living With Christopher Walken & Teach Jimmy Fallon to Fly

Allison Williams took a break from Peter Pan Live! rehearsals on Long Island to stop by The Tonight Show on November 17, where she discussed sharing a hotel with the swiniest swine in the world: Christopher Walken. Apparently, both are taking their character development incredibly seriously, even down to their lunch orders. Williams, who will play the titular Boy Who Wouldn’t Grow Up, ordered “a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, because I’m American and I’m not dumb.” Walken, preparing to take on the role of Captain Hook, had something more nautical in mind: two pounds of smoked salmon. We’d totally be pirates if it meant unlimited lox. Take a look at the clips below, including Jimmy Fallon’s flying lesson from Williams herself! You can see her take flight live on December 4.