It Only Takes a Taste! Watch Waitress' Jessie Mueller Eat Pie & Sing Some Carole King For Old Times' Sake

Pie is kind of a big deal in the Sara Bareilles-scored musical Waitress, which recently nabbed four Tony Award nominations. Jessie Mueller received a nod for her powerful role as Jenna, who pours her frustrations and triumphs into the creatively titled pies she makes. Visting The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on May 12, Mueller revealed that she does not get to indulge in the pies her character bakes eight shows a week. Ever the late night gentleman, Colbert brought out a lovely pecan pie for the two to enjoy. In exchange, Mueller threw it back with singing "Will You Love Me Tomorrow" from Beautiful: The Carole King Musical, for which she earned her first Tony Award. Enjoy the sweet treat below!