"I was introduced to this play on TikTok and I was immediately hooked. The chemistry on stage was beautiful. I wish I could watch it over and over "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 2, 2025
AMAZING
"One of the most entertaining plays I’ve ever seen. The acting was sensational, and I couldn’t believe how quickly the time went. I could totally see it again."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 10, 2026
Amazing performance
"Amazing and creative use of luggage as scenery. So seamless — Almost forget they were pieces of luggage. And the voices, music and actors. This is a show that is NOT to be missed!! Get your tickets NOW!"
...
Read more
Richard U from Fredericksburg on Feb 9, 2026
Amazing voices and lots of laughter
"The actors had amazing voices and drew you into the story with humor. Very clever set that worked for every scene and allowed the actors to move around without having to do set changes. Definitely recommend. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 24, 2026
Comedy with Layers: Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York
"What an absolute delight! This show was laugh-out-loud funny from start to finish, with sharp writing and perfectly timed humor that kept the audience engaged throughout. The chemistry between the leads was electric—Sam Tutty and Christiani Pitts were nothing short of fantastic. Tutty brought a charming awkwardness that made his character instantly lovable, while Pitts delivered a vibrant, heartfelt performance that balanced comedy with genuine emotion.
The pacing was spot-on, and the quirky premise unfolded in a way that felt fresh and unpredictable. It’s rare to find a production that combines humor, heart, and originality so seamlessly, but this one nails it. If you’re looking for a feel-good, hilarious night at the theater, Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York is a must-see!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 12, 2026
The title is straight to the point
"I love that the 2 actors kept my attention and it was a great show"
...
Read more
Sandra M from DAYTONA BEACH on Jan 11, 2026
A Two-Person Phenomenon!
""Two Strangers" is a funny feel-good show that definitely pulls on your heart-strings! It does contain adult themes, the set design is amazing and creative, but minimal. I would leave the children at home for this one. The songs are powerful and moving, and many have quickly become earworms around our house! This show is fantastic and surprising, even though there are only 2 actors. I would definitely recommend it to a friend."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 5, 2026
Outstanding
"Very creative show…the two performers were fabulous"
...
Read more
Donna C from Quincy on Jan 3, 2026
Clever and funny
"A fantastic show with a lot of moments of funny insight into human longing for happiness."
...
Read more
Hansjoerg T from Koeln on Dec 31, 2025
Thoroughly Enjoyable
"A funny, sweet dialogue between two young people. Musical comedy & human drama combined. Leaves you feeling good. "
...
Read more
Maureen K from Flushing on Dec 22, 2025
Fun and uplifting entertainment
"Clever jokes that carried throughout the show. Fantastic performances, incredible musicians, clever set, loved everything about it. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 19, 2025
Utterly charming!
"This sweet little show is bright with talented co-stars, ingenious set design and a story made alive by terrific acting. A story where you are rooting for each of the characters to find a way to “be happy”!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 8, 2026
Great show
"The acting and singing were incredible. The writing was witty and fun. I thought the set was very creative, and the story itself was strong and sweet."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 26, 2026
Its not about baked goods.
"Well written comedy. The two actors played off each other brilliantly. "
...
Read more
Patrick W from Lansing on Dec 31, 2025
A Hallmark movie on stage.
"This is a fun romcom. Nothing more nothing less. It is a good time. I loved it .It is amazing that just two performers carried the whole thing."
...
Read more
Danny B from burbank on Dec 4, 2025
My first Broadway show
"This was my first experience seeing a show on Broadway and I was not disappointed. The actors were great, loved the songs, and was pleasantly surprised at the size of the venue (I assumed they were all huge). I would definitely recommend this show."
...
Read more
Paula S from Charleston on Nov 27, 2025
Vert talented actors
"The acting, singing, and dancing were great. I did have some trouble hearing the lyrics especially when they were rapping. The sound in my audio headset was a bit garbled. Some very funny scenes and great for native New Yorkers."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 23, 2025
Amazing cast, very fun show
"With only two cast members, the story is very personal. I loved the dynamic and changing relationship between the two characters. The songs are solid and catchy despite a lackluster instrumentation. The comedy is excellent and rarely, if ever, falls flat. I'd definitely recommend, it's very fun, even if it's not my favorite musical ever. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 20, 2026
Mixed Feelings
"I really wanted to like this show. I had so looked forward to it.
I liked Christiani Pitts very much. She is a great actress and has a beautiful voice.
Some of the “ballads” were beautiful.
The first act there was just not enough story, movement for me; just kind of entertaining. Did get better the second act, much more development of story.
There were 2 things that really bothered me. Let me say I am hearing impaired, which possibly added to my problems with the show. However, I go to shows all the time and don’t experience the problems I had with Two Strangers.
First, Sam Tutty talked so fast I had trouble understanding him. I did not have that problem with Christiani at all.
Second the orchestra was far too loud made it difficult to hear the vocals.
I would like to add that I had excellent seats, Row 4, right in the center and I had a hearing device.
"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 8, 2026
I wish
"I really wanted to like this production. I went into it no real information outside of the synopsis and commercials I had seen. Unfortunately, the plot line was dull. The staging was boring, and the music was unremarkable. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 1, 2026
Cliche
"Fine talent. Impressive that they held the show for two hours, but the writing was boring and unoriginal. Some songs felt like AI slop. The set felt overly and unintelligently simplified. It wasn't worth the ticket."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 20, 2026
I did not like it. We found it hard to understand,.
"Not our cup of tea."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 21, 2026
Not a Broadway worthy show
"While the performers had nice singing voices, the show was lackluster. It reminded me of a summer camp musical. Not worth the price of a Broadway ticket. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 29, 2025
Viewing 101-123 of 123
About
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
Fall in love with New York City again, or for the first time, at Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York), now on Broadway. A New York Times Critics’ Pick, Two Strangers is “an effervescent new musical comedy that delivers lavishly on laughter, escape, and fantasy.”
You’ll meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. And you’ll meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport. These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets, and second chances.
The Boston Globe proclaims, Two Strangers is “IRRESISTIBLE! Clever, funny, and delightfully surprising!”, and it has been named on the Best of 2025 lists from USA Today, Entertainment Weekly and New York Theatre Guide.
For lifelong New Yorkers and first-time visitors alike, Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) sparks a renewed sense of wonder for the city, in what The Wall Street Journal’s Charles Passy hails as “a thoroughly beguiling ode to the Big Apple!”
