"The actors are great. While not a typical musical with big song and dance routines the story, delivery and book are outstanding."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 23, 2026
Wonderful show
"The music and subject matter was most enjoyable. I loved this show "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 23, 2026
One of the best shows I’ve seen in a long time.
"It goes to show you there is still talent out there. Two great actors, a great script, and a simple stage proves a show that makes you laugh, have warm feelings can still be made. Enough of shows about live and dead singers and we don’t need over the top staging which is one of the reason tickets are so expensive. In London I see shows for a third of the price here. Yes, sets are not over the top but as this show proves you don’t need that excess."
...
Read more
James F from Baltimore on Aug 19, 2026
A Star is Born
"Both actors are incredible, but Sam Tutty is going to be the next big thing. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 17, 2026
Just the two of us…
"There may be only two performers on the stage, but they will transport you all around NY with a smile, a song, a romance and a solid story. Amazing vocals, simple yet poignant staging. This is feel good live theatre."
...
Read more
Conrad C from Cathedral City on Aug 17, 2026
Highly recommend!
"This show was clever, sweet, funny and unexpected. Highly recommend. "
...
Read more
Megan H from Mission Hills on Aug 16, 2026
Brilliant!
"An entertainingly brilliant exploration of the human condition."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 15, 2026
My Granddaughter Wanted to See It! I didn't. I took her and I LOVED it!
"Funny -- Sad!
Wonderful performers!
A treat!"
...
Read more
Alan D from New Rochelle on Aug 13, 2026
FABULOUS
"I love Sam Tutty. He is a brilliant actor with an incredible voice and a perfect comedic affect. I enjoy watching and listening to him!!
Christiani is a beautiful and talented artist as well.
Sam carries the show and she is a good balance for him."
...
Read more
Jani M from Oyster Bay on Aug 12, 2026
The FUNNIEST Show I've Ever Seen
"I was surprised by how funny the show was, and how great it was. I never expected to laugh as much as I did, the banter was so perfect and the script is brilliantly written. We also got our Playbills signed by the actors they were super nice."
...
Read more
Sirena R from Windsor on Aug 12, 2026
Vibrant with excellent acting
"Excellent plot. Great singing and dancing! Totally enjoyable!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 12, 2026
Worth every penny!
"Excellent chemistry between the actors! Superb musicianship from everyone involved, and they were clearly enjoying performing for us! Can't wait to go back to see it again. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 9, 2026
Truly underrated show
"I first heard the opening number "New York" in YouTube last year, and I couldn't get the damn tune out of my head. Luckily, I had the chance to watch it last week. Even though I was darn disappointed that Sam Tutty was not playing Dougal - I was nevertheless satisfied with the performance.
I hope more people will watch this show. I feel that this is an underrated show - I didn't see much advertisement for this show in Times Square. It is a must watch for first timers in New York (like me). Watch this guys - you will enjoy it for sure."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 6, 2026
A must see
"I thought it was so creative and was the perfect amount of time. It was adorable and fun, yet consisted of more serious storylines, and most of all I loved it because I thought it was hilarious. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 3, 2026
Wonderful under the radar musical
"Would definitely recommend this be a plan A musical for someone making a trip for Broadway. Very funny, well written, good songs, and the two stars are terrific."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 2, 2026
A great time
"A beautifully executed two-person production. I was blown away by the incredible talent of both actors—their chemistry was undeniable, and their vocal performances were exceptional. Every detail, from the thoughtfully crafted script to the simplicity and versatility of the set design, felt intentional and added depth to the story. It was entertaining, genuinely funny, and full of substance. Five stars without hesitation!"
...
Read more
jeanine d from Merrick on Aug 1, 2026
Amazing show
"Incredible talent, funny and engaging. Ingenious staging with minimal sets. Lots of fun."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jul 29, 2026
loved it
"Amazing set, well done. Great for someone visiting New York. A fun way to experience NYC...China Town, the Plaza, Rockefeller Center, subway, all from the comfort of the theater.
"
...
Read more
heather e from Gotha on Jul 28, 2026
Our New Favorite!
"Sam is absolutely amazing as Dougal, he’s magic on stage."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jul 26, 2026
Charming and funny.
"Good story, funny, music was good and excellent performance by actors."
...
Read more
Howard G from Commack on Jul 23, 2026
Brilliant duo
"Cosmo was right when they called this the “feel-good musical of the year”"
...
Read more
Michael A from Durham on Jul 20, 2026
This Musical Play Was Just Wonderful!!
"I absolutely loved the whole show! For only a two person play it was amazing & very believable! The characters they played were very believable! The setting was just perfect! The story line was spot on. I had a smile on my face the whole performance. The actors were superb! Their voices were amazing! What more could you ask for in seeing a Broadway Show in NYC?! I would see it again. I highly recommend this play and give it an A+"
...
Read more
John M from Mountain Top on Jul 19, 2026
Out of this world amazing performance!
"The two of them had an amazing performance! They were so dynamic and engaging. The play kept us captivated the entire time and the songs were so catchy. Also, had us laughing throughout! Great overall experience "
...
Read more
Stephanie S from Halethorpe on Jul 19, 2026
Really great!
"What a wonderful play! Great story! Great Acting!"
...
Read more
William S from Leland on Jul 16, 2026
Great fun to watch
"Funny Story, two strangers enjoying a funny trip through New York. Great songs and really good actors."
...
Read more
Tanja K from Bielefeld on Jul 15, 2026
Viewing 51-75 of 320
About
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
You’ll meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. And you’ll meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport. These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets, and second chances.
