"It was a high energy show with a fabulous stage set. The actors were outstanding and unbelievably talented! They both had amazing voices! The story is very clever and humorous, but with a lot of thought and heart.
Hope it wins a lot of Tony’s! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 28, 2026
Outstanding!
"One of the best shows I’ve seen in quite some time! Great storyline, excellent singing, and wonderful set. A must see for sure!"
...
Read more
Kristine L from Anaheim on May 24, 2026
Great fun empowering show
"The two actors were great - the story was intriguing - twist and turns with wonderful songs and touching moments that I think pretty much everyone in the audience could relate to in someway or another.
The best part was the interactive aspect of the whole thing with the audience and the actors, and everyone just being together celebrating going through this experience"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 21, 2026
Fantastic show
"The performers are magical."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 16, 2026
Funny show
"The show was super funny with great jokes. More adult humor so that is why i would not recommend it for children. The actors were extremely talented. The stage was very unique and I loved how it was used. I wish I bought tickets not at the top though. Hard to see the entire stage. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 16, 2026
Electrifying fun
"This musical was amazing. I laughed, I cried, I got the songs stuck in my head for days. I highly recommend this for anyone looking for a wonderful, thought provoking show."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 14, 2026
Time to Laugh!
"The performers were lively and funny! They played off each other so well! The songs along with their voices added to the play! It was a nice getaway from our world! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 11, 2026
Excellent!
"I was very surprised it was a cast of 2….but it was more than enough!! Funny and fun. Excellent performance!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 11, 2026
Can't stop smiling! Captured NYC from both resident and tourist views.
"Stage sets looked simple but were constantly surprising! Actors were brilliant. A lot of heavy lifting for a 2 person show. A delight to see the musicians who were perfect not only for musical numbers but for vibe."
...
Read more
Lynette DuClos A from Santa Cruz on May 7, 2026
Great Performance of Both
"It was great to see how the actors where feeling their individual characters.
I had a lot of fun! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 2, 2026
Wow!!
"Just wonderful! Great energy, singing and clever banter! I was entertained from start to finish. "
...
Read more
Gail F from Coldspring on Apr 26, 2026
Brought some sunshine to a very dreary, rainy day
"The show was recommended to me. I honestly didn’t know what to expect. I totally enjoyed it. The comedy, music and dancing.
Performers were top of the line! Loved the way the luggage carousel was used as props!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Apr 26, 2026
A delightful performance
"We quite enjoyed Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York). The music was very good, the writing well done, and the performers were excellent. "
...
Read more
Rosemary H from MINNEAPOLIS on Apr 25, 2026
Wonderful story and great performances!
""Dougal" has perfected the role that he has played in so many theaters, and "Robin" has an amazing voice and presence. They both brought a great story to life in an exciting and entertaining way.
"
...
Read more
LISA W from DOYLESTOWN on Apr 23, 2026
2 person smash
"Beautiful voices, simple, engaging stage, and a hilarious , heartwarming , feel good story. All of the audience is richer upon seeing this production "
...
Read more
Kevin B from Hershey on Apr 20, 2026
You'll want to go back again!
"This show was funny, and the actors have such incredible stage presence they will become your favorites for sure! We even waited for a photo with Sam Tutty at the stage door afterward, and that's not something we ever do after a show. He was as warm and friendly in person as his character is on stage. Christiani Pitts is a perfect compliment to him and just as amazing. Together they are a remarkable, funny and loveable team!"
"This play is funny & poignant dealing with issues which are as timeless as they are relevant. It is beautifully acted by both characters. Heartwarming and fun. Your time and money will be well spent. "
...
Read more
Noel P from East northport on Apr 18, 2026
Fantastic entertaining musical.
"This was a fantastic experiance. My wife and I from England together with our son and daughter in law who is from California all greatly enjoyed the show. The cast of 2 gave a remarkable performance with humour and catchy songs and what looked like a very simple set design (I'm sure it wasn't) greatly added to the whole effect. A truely memorable experiance."
...
Read more
Robert Akeroyd B from Ludham on Apr 17, 2026
Very entertaining, even for those who don't love musicals.
"This show was so entertaining and there was no time for boredom or yawns. I brought my husband to the show and he's somebody who generally doesn't love musicals and often falls asleep during the show. Not this time, he was wide awake and laughing the entire time. We also brought our teenage daughters and they loved it! First Broadway show for them was a win!"
...
Read more
Erin L from Newburyport on Apr 13, 2026
Charming and heartwarming
"Two strangers who share a couple of days in New York City is funny, relatable, and heartwarming. Would love to see it again! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Apr 6, 2026
20 stars for sure
"This is one of my all time favorite shows ever!! I saw clips online and decided I had to come to NYC from Chicago to see it and it was just as good as I dreamed it would be. Christiani Pitts and Sam Tutty were absolutely stunning in this! Their voices were perfection in this musical. Their chemistry was magical a once in a lifetime match. I never wanted it to end. As for kids? Maybe a little mature for young kids but older kids will love the music and the story! Thank you for giving us the most amazing evening and it was the absolute highlight of our trip. After the show the cast was so sweet and signed our playbills and chatted with us and were so kind. Those will be going on the wall as soon as I get home!! Do not miss this musical!! I will hopefully get to see it again!! "
...
Read more
Kirsten B from Crystal Lake on Apr 5, 2026
What a wonderful show!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
"Wit…fast pace…acting and music. Only reason to not recommend for children was sexual overtones and some language. Other than that a most enjoyable show and would highly recommend. "
"I loved the story line. Some of the plots were not obvious, you had to think about them before they hit you. Clever writing! Very very funny. Shows about family dynamics and relationships are timeless - this play made these dyamics feel very current.
The acting and singing were great! And being a 2-person play makes it even more fabulous!"
...
Read more
Donna D A from Silver Spring on Apr 5, 2026
I was laughing from the time the show started
"This show was great. Had heard mixed reviews and do not understand why at all - it was amazing."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Apr 5, 2026
Viewing 51-75 of 236
About
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
You’ll meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. And you’ll meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport. These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets, and second chances.
