"Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York) is one of those rare shows that feels instantly alive. From the opening moments, it establishes itself as a smart, contemporary romcom that avoids the usual traps. It’s romantic without being cheesy, funny without winking too hard at itself, and sincere without ever feeling corny.
The music is sharp and modern, with songs that are genuinely catchy while still doing real character work. The lyrics are clever and confident, trusting the audience to keep up. Performances are excellent, anchored by leads with natural chemistry and emotional range that make the relationship feel earned rather than manufactured.
The staging is inventive and fluid, using space and movement to capture the pace and energy of New York City without overcomplication. Sound design is clean and powerful, letting both humor and heart land exactly as intended.
By the end, it feels complete, joyful, and surprisingly resonant. A modern musical that knows exactly what it is and executes it beautifully.
My 9year old loved it, but he “plays up” not sure I’d bring other kids, he’s just a stud."
...
Read more
David G from Cranston on Jan 5, 2026
A Love Letter To NYC
"When I tell you I smiled through this whole show; I honestly did. This show is not only a story bout serendipitous love, but also a love letter to the city of New York. Go see it. I highly recommend it. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 4, 2026
This show was an absolute hit!!
"This show was very funny, had good music with words you could actually hear (so many shows have music so loud the words are lost!) and two wonderful actors!! I have recommended this show to others and everyone loves it!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 4, 2026
Delightful Performance!
"Christiani Pitts and Vincent Michael were amazing! Fantastic singing and they did a phenomenal job performing the entire show together! We loved it!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 4, 2026
A fun musical romp through New York
"Show that was fast moving and fun. Great relationship built throughout. Great plot twists. Catchy songs and talented actors. "
...
Read more
Michelle R from Pittsburgh on Jan 1, 2026
Utterly charming and emotional show
"There’s nothing that I didn’t like. The show is such a charming, fun and surprisingly emotional show. I saw Doug’s Stand-by and he gave an incredibly performance. I was surprised at how moved I was in the second act. I was completely engaged the whole show. I would definitely see the show again. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 30, 2025
Utterly Delightful!
"Such a charming story, loved the music and the set design. It was a lovely afternoon and I was very happy that I went to see it! Both actors were amazing! 👏👏👏👏👏"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 29, 2025
Loved it!
"What a fun and feel good show! All eleven in our group loved it! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 29, 2025
Fun, heartwarming , relatable
"The acting was wonderful. The storyline was very clever. If you are a New Yorker you’d love it. Makes you laugh. Great songs! Loved it!! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 27, 2025
Wonderfully entertaining!
"We enjoyed the show. Amazing that two actors were able to carry an entire show and made it work with such a simplistic set! Highly recommend. "
...
Read more
Holly C from Rolesville on Dec 27, 2025
Visiting from CA
"My wife and I found the music and dialogue creative, witty and funny, the actors extremely talented, and the venue very intimate. Great night out in New York."
...
Read more
Albert V from El Cajon on Dec 27, 2025
Well written and well acted
"As a two person show, the musical was very entertaining"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 27, 2025
Laugh and cry
"A touching story, well written and acted. The humor catches you from the start and the mystery surrounding both characters unravels at the perfect pace. You enjoy getting close to these characters as they unfold. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 22, 2025
Magnificent
"Great comedy, great musical, absolutely fantastic. What a night out!"
...
Read more
Richard T from London on Dec 22, 2025
Amazing show!
"Witty and funny! Excellent execution and performance from the cast! Sam was flawless and hilarious, while Christiani brought depth to this masterpiece!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 22, 2025
Best musical I’ve seen in years!
"Actors were amazing and creative staging
"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 20, 2025
What a pleasant surprise!
"The show was captivating from beginning to end. The talent was so strong to be able to move the story along and keep your interest all the way through. You rooted for the characters like they had become friends."
...
Read more
Mary Ann H from Palm Harbor on Dec 20, 2025
Great show for NYC Christmas weekend visit
"Story was good and meaningful. Music and performances were very good and entertaining. "
...
Read more
Charles H from Bradfordwoods on Dec 20, 2025
Phenomenal Performance!
"We absolutely loved this show! Amazing.Do not miss this one. "
...
Read more
Kim S from Windermere on Dec 19, 2025
Laughed so hard I cried!
"I had to take off my glasses 3 times to wipe my tears from how hard I was laughing. Knew nothing about the story before seeing the show, and it was one of the best nights on Broadway I’ve ever had! You will have such a good time at Two Strangers!"
...
Read more
Kristina B from Hamilton on Dec 17, 2025
The icing on the cake…
"This musical was absolutely incredible, funny, and entertaining. The storyline definitely will keep you engaged not to mention the back and forth quips between the two of them. They carried this musical entirely and I stand amazed in how they executed this in a dramatic, spectacular way. It is truly a must see!!! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 15, 2025
Incredible Show!!!
"I went to see the show this past Saturday evening. Amazing performers, phenomenal voices and worth every penny!! Such a beautiful and funny show!! I highly recommend it and you won’t be disappointed 🤩🤩🤩🤩"
...
Read more
Stacy M from Brooklyn on Dec 15, 2025
Funny and new.
"Really enjoyed this play. It is fresh and very funny. Everyone seemed to really enjoy it. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 15, 2025
FABULOUS SHOW
"LOVED THIS SHOW! From the opening number to the end! The singing was stellar! The performers were equally funny and dramatic. They each did such a fantastic job of drawing you into their characters. Would see this again! LOVED IT!!!!!"
...
Read more
Barbara A from Slippery Rock on Dec 15, 2025
Wonderful story and thoughtful
"The 2 actors were perfect. The story was laugh out loud funny at parts and heartfelt in parts. The band, the set and the story were super. I suggest everyone try this show out when in NYC"
...
Read more
Brian R from Parkland on Dec 14, 2025
Viewing 126-150 of 236
About
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
You’ll meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. And you’ll meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport. These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets, and second chances.
