Broadway Guides
Show Guides

The Best Off-Broadway Shows in 2026

Last updated Oct. 13, 2026 by Broadway.com Staff
Lead image for the article The Best Off-Broadway Shows in 2026
Illustration: Jillian Goeler

Looking to explore more of New York City's theater scene? Off-Broadway shows offer an exciting alternative to Broadway, with affordable ticket prices, a variety of productions and intimate venues that bring you closer to the action.

The term "off-Broadway" refers to the size of a production's theater, typically 499 seats or less. While some off-Broadway theaters are located away from the Broadway Theatre District, many are located in midtown Manhattan, just steps from Broadway. 

From funny farces to new musicals to family-friendly experiences, there's truly something for everyone off-Broadway!

What You'll Learn About

Amaze Magic

Now Open
Revolutionary magician Jamie Allan brings his record-shattering spectacle to New York City! Amaze Magic weaves storytelling, dazzling visual effects, mesmerizing sleight-of-hand and more into an unforgettable show that the whole family will enjoy. Get tickets to Amaze Magic off-Broadway!

 

Jamie Allan performs magic in Amaze off-Broadway
Jamie Allan in Amaze Magic
(Photo: Danny Kaan)

Little Shop of Horrors

Now Open
Head "Downtown" and catch this cult favorite musical live on stage! Based on the film of the same name, Little Shop of Horrors follows the meek Seymour as he navigates his crush on coworker Audrey and the needs of increasingly demanding houseplant.  Get tickets to Little Shop of Horrors off-Broadway!
 
Seymour and Audrey chat in off-Broadway's Little Shop of Horrors
Ethan Slater and Betsy Wolfe in Little Shop of Horrors
(Photo: Emilio Madrid)

The Play That Goes Wrong

Now Open

A celebration of the best of live theater... and the worst! Get ready to laugh at this play within a play, where everything that can go wrong, does. Get tickets to The Play That Goes Wrong off-Broadway!

the cast of The Play That Goes Wrong stand in a living room holding a grandfather clock
The cast of The Play That Goes Wrong
(Photo: Jeremy Daniel)

Gazillion Bubble Show


Now Open; Closes January 18, 2027
A magical interactive experience for kids of all ages! Showcasing the bubble artistry of the Yang family, Gazillion Bubble Show features mind-blowing bubble magic, spectacular laser light effects and the opportunity to be IN a bubble yourself. Get tickets to Gazillion Bubble Show off-Broadway!

 

A performer sticks her arm into a large bubble in off-Broadway's Gazillion Bubble Show
Gazillion Bubble Show
(Photo: Kyle Foreman)

Masquerade

Now Open

Experience the new immersive production of The Phantom of the Opera, where audiences move through the music and mystery of Andrew Lloyd Webber's classic. Get tickets to Masquerade off-Broadway!

the spellers circle around the microphone in The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
A scene from Masquerade
(Photo courtesy of The Pekoe Group)

Midnight

Now in Previews; Opens October 15, 2026; Closes November 8, 2026

Set in the American South during the 19th century, Todrick Hall's new musical explores love, identity, empathy and the humanity that connects us across the boundaries of race, class and expectation.  Get tickets to Midnight off-Broadway!

Todrick Hall and Jeremy Beloate in Midnight
(Photo: Valerie Terranova)

The Heart

Now in Previews; Opens October 29, 2026; Closes December 6, 2026
Based on Maylis de Kerangal’s 2014 novel Réparer les vivants, this new musical centers on the beating heart that drives two families and a medical team through 24 hours that couldn't matter more. Get tickets to The Heart off-Broadway!

 

Jamie Allan performs magic in Amaze off-Broadway
Heidi Blickenstaff and the cast of The Heart
(Photo: Matthew Murphy)

Keep in mind that some off-Broadway theaters are located outside of Times Square. Be sure to check on the location of your show before heading out the door!
 

 

Don’t see what you’re looking for?
Ask us for help or send a suggestion.
Contact Us
Back to Top