Review Roundup: Fan Reviews for the Best Broadway Shows in NYC

Last updated Nov. 19, 2025 by Broadway.com Staff

Illustration: Jillian Goeler

Still not sure which shows you want to see on your trip to New York City? After over 25 years in the business, Broadway.com is a leading destination for Broadway tickets, and our customers know what they're talking about! Here's what our customers are saying about Broadway's hottest shows.

What You'll Learn About

& Juliet Reviews

There's life after Romeo at this larger-than-life musical by the Emmy-winning writer from Schitt's Creek and pop music's #1 hitmaker.

"Highly entertaining. Very clever script. Strong themes about relationships and confidence. Excellent acting. Wonderful music. Thoroughly loved the performance.”
Vanessa C, New York
"All around feel good show! I think this was hands down the most enjoyable show I've seen on broadway. It was fun, plenty of 90s nostalgia, a captivating coming of age story, that was incredibly well written and choreographed with the songs. Everything worked flawlessly together. I would highly recommend!"
John S, Sloatsburg
"Absolutely brilliant! My wife and I took our 12 and 9 year old daughters to & Juliet and we had a blast! The writing was brilliant and the acting superb. It was really cool to see the various pop songs' lyrics fit in perfectly with the storyline. If you are in NYC, you have GOT to see this musical! We would see it again in a heartbeat! Nice job!"
Mark A, Rockville

Aladdin Reviews

Head to Agrabah in Aladdin, where the beloved Disney story is brought to thrilling theatrical life.

"I absolutely loved it! Not only is the story romantic, funny, and heartfelt — the show itself brilliantly celebrated every moment of Aladdin. It brought the Disney classic to life as a dazzling spectacle: funny, engaging, hilarious, fascinating, and bursting with festive energy. A true explosion of joy, laughter, and beauty. Thank you!"
Diana K, Delft
"Magical! This was a fantastic show! The entire experience from beginning to end was wonderful. We entered immediately and got my 7 year old son a booster seat for better viewing. He was transfixed. From the colorful costumes, to the catchy tunes, and funny characters - we were all smiles! This is a great first show for children ages 6 and up!”
Lisa B, Brooklyn
"A magical first Broadway experience. This was my very first live theatre experience, and I absolutely loved it! The performances were outstanding, with every actor bringing so much energy and life to the stage. The coordination between the cast, orchestra, and choreography was seamless, making each scene flow beautifully. The special effects were simply incredible — from dazzling costume changes to the magic carpet ride, it felt truly magical. Aladdin was the perfect introduction to Broadway for me, and I left the theatre smiling from ear to ear.
Zeeahan S, Sydney

Art Reviews

Bobby Cannavale, James Corden and Neil Patrick Harris star in Yasmina Reza's Tony-winning play featuring minimalist art, maximalist laughs and a moving look at what we really see and forgive in the people we love.

"A wonderfully entertaining threesome of superb actors. The three stars are perfection! While James Corden's role gets the most laughs due to the script, both Bobby Carnavale and Neil Patrick Harris are terrific. This is pure entertainment, provided by polished and adorable professionals from start to finish. The 90 minutes flew by, and the audience loved every second."
Martin S, Plainview
"Very unique! We enjoyed this very much, so thought provoking! Made me feel very uncomfortable at times, the discourse was a LOT, but so well done! Standing ovation from the whole theater. Set design, lighting, music were key elements done very well, added a lot to the experience. Definitely not a comedy, and LOTS of foul language. Highly recommend!"
Sheila H, Alamo

Chicago Reviews

Now in its 28th year on Broadway, the Tony-winning revival of Kander and Ebb's classic musical will razzle dazzle you.

"Blazing hot and powerful fun. From the 1st song, the audience is brought into a world of naughtiness, sexuality, murder, and wrongdoing. It is intriguing, always has been for me and draws me into wanting to be with the characters. I love how all of the characters find their ways of engaging the audience. I have seen Chicago on Broadway four times and will continue to come because each time, I see more to each character and how they evolve. I love Chicago."
Jane C, Columbia
"A masterclass in acting. One of the people in my group called it a masterclass in acting and he was not wrong! It was so impressive how well the story was told without massive set changes or numerous costume changes. We were in the orchestra and we could see all of the facial expressions and everything so well. It was all just amazing.”
Natalie L, Endwell
"Amazing performance! Loved, loved, loved this show! The singing and dancing were beyond amazing. The story is captivating and I marveled at the sheer talent of all the actors in this show! A must see!"
Deborah L, Fairfax Station

Death Becomes Her Reviews

Madeline Ashton and Helen Sharp take the stage in the musical adaptation of the cult favorite 1992 film of the same name.

" Laugh out loud hilarious. Similar to some other more recent musicals, Death Becomes Her is an over-the-top romp with some wonderful special effects. Our cast was simply incredible and we left the show with stitches in our side. Definitely worth a viewing!"
Jennifer J, Oshkosh
"Incredible. Oh my goodness! This show is incredible! The singing, the dancing, the acting, the sets...seriously one of the best Broadway shows I have ever seen. And I have seen a lot! It is absolutely hilarious, too. The entire cast should receive Tonys! Loved it!.”
Sherry M, Jasper
"Excellent performance. It was a great show. The characters did a great job making it a very lively and fun performance. Excellent singing and dance performances by the characters. Great effects, simple but really nice to watch. The show is something great for everyone who likes the movie or just looking for a fun musical."
Thomas S, East Windsor

Hadestown Reviews

Head way down to the underworld in this Tony-winning musical that intertwines the mythical tales of both Orpheus & Eurydice and Hades & Persephone.

"Fabulous experience. The music, the cast, the sets, the lighting, the dance, the musicians—all were amazing. I do not generally like modern musicals, but this one was mesmerizing and an emotional experience. It was the first night for the new set of principal actors and they carried it off perfectly."
Amy S, Seattle
"Incredible. Fantastic production! Absolutely loved Hadestown. The performance was powerful. Incredible. Every member of the cast and musicians were fantastic. Set design, costumes, everything added to the magic."
Kimberly H, Lunenberg
"Poignant and impactful. The vocal talent and intensity felt through the emotions of the actors left you emotionally charged!"
Laura G, Bel Air

Hamilton Reviews

Get a fresh look at the Founding Fathers in Lin-Manuel Miranda's Tony-winning musical.

"Breathtaking! Hamilton remains one of the most groundbreaking musicals on Broadway. We had an incredible time. The cast were nothing short of magnificent. Our son is 11 and although the show is long-ish, and does have adult themes, it held his focus throughout. If you only have time for one show in town, make it this one. You won’t be disappointed."
Mark G, Marshfield
"What a wonderful show! Energy is one word that describes Hamilton so well. The dancing, singing and story were outstanding. We saw the play with our ten year old granddaughter, who absolutely loved it. Being 75 years old, I had somewhat of a difficult time with the rap but I attributed that as generational. All in all, it was a fabulous show."
Murray B, Santa Fe
"Brought to tears. What a wonderful show of talent!! The composition and orchestration of music, the choreography, staging...All of this was so extraordinary! But what brought me to tears was the wonderful emotional delivery by the main characters. They were exceptional!"
Mary T, Philadelphia

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Reviews

Experience the wizarding world like never before at this Tony Award-winning spectacle.

"Absolutely loved the show. This show captivated me and my daughter from beginning to end. Particularly I was amazed by the special effects. It was like experiencing magic. We also thought the acting was stellar."
Dag L, Oslo
"Amazing storyline. The performances were incredible from start to finish. I took my 13yr year old grandson with his friend and they both loved it. I would highly recommend it."
Andrea A, Highland Mills
"Crowd interactive. From the moment the play began, it was a masterclass in immersive storytelling. The stage underwent mesmerizing transformations that captured my attention immediately and never let go. Every element—the evocative costumes, the haunting music, and the dramatic lighting—worked in perfect harmony to represent the story's world. Particularly brilliant was the use of props like lamps and clocks, which, paired with the clever interplay of light and shadow, guided us through the narrative and kept us utterly engaged. The production is filled with moments of pure theatrical magic that are best experienced firsthand. I wouldn't dream of spoiling them; this is a show that simply must be seen to be believed."
Susana P, Canterbury

Hell's Kitchen Reviews

The hit musical inspired by the life, music, and community of Grammy winner Alicia Keys.

"Heartwarming and sensational! A phenomenal show. The cast and crew were incredible. I loved how Alicia Keys music was used to tell this beautiful story of a complicated relationship between a mother and daughter. I highly recommend this show!"
Kara W, St. Albert
"One of the best shows I have seen! From the minute the show started, we were captivated! The singing was incredible and the story was really entertaining. We laughed and we cried, our whole family loved the show!"
Carmen C, Vancouver
"Great production, fabulous cast. This show is captivating from start to finish. Keys' music is incredible on its own. Paired with this production, it's phenomenal. This is a must see in my opinion."
Brian M, Oklahoma City

Just In Time Reviews

Jonathan Groff stars as the legendary Bobby Darin in this immersive Broadway musical.

"Smaller venue, better experience. This venue is smaller than the usual Broadway theatre. Having such a smaller venue allowed the experience to feel more personal & special. Instead of just watching a show, I felt that I was actually a part of the show. Being so close to the actors changed the experience of Broadway for me in the best way ever. I will forever be replaying this show & experience in my head!"
Kristina C, Trussville
"The best show in years. Groff was amazing. If you can see one show this year, THIS IS THE ONE TO SEE. Scripting, performances, music, staging are the very best. Cudos to Jonathan and the other performers. Band is terrific and staging is magnificent."
Philip B, Delray
"Spectacular show. Spectacular production in every respect. The orchestra and music was wonderful, the cabaret style theater and the sets terrific, and the entire cast sang and danced their ways into the hearts of the audience. And … the performance by Jonathan Groff was remarkable. Great telling of the life and times of Bobby Darin. This show was stunning and as much fun as any musical I have ever experienced."
Paul R, South Orleans

Mamma Mia! Reviews

The smash hit musical featuring the songs of ABBA is back on Broadway for a limited run.

"The show was absolutely amazing! I absolutely loved it. Mamma Mia was absolutely amazing! The show was full of energy, great music, and so much fun. The artists played their best and brought so much joy to the stage—I loved every moment"
Irina S, South Weymouth
"Amazing show. Fun, funny and entertaining from the moment the curtain rose. Familiar music, great vocals and the dancing was incredible. The ensemble was mesmerizing. Even the choreography of the scene changes was interesting. My sister, who had seen an earlier Broadway production of Mamma Mia, thought this one was better. Loved every second of it!"
Mark S, Belmont
"Fantastic! Mamma Mia is a fabulous Broadway show! A must see! There are so many great songs, I could not help but dance (appropriately) in my seat while singing along in my head! The actors are amazing! I don't want to spoil it, but wow, just wow when the Winner Takes All is sung! Get ready for goosebumps! I loved the interactive encore! I danced and sang along with abandon! We talked about the play the entire ride home, of course, while listening to ABBA! I would love to see it again! Get your tickets while you can. You will be so glad that you did! Amazing job by all!!"
Trisha D, Port Jervis

Maybe Happy Ending Reviews

The Tony-winning musical that tells the deeply human story of a chance encounter that sparks connection, adventure, and maybe even love.

"Sharp, original and engaging.This show had the most original staging I have ever seen. It used a soft and gentle touch to illuminate both the joys and sorrows of friendship and relationships. It mixed reality and fantasy in a palatable way. Although the songs are not memorable like some shows, the singing was superb and very satisfying. Good for kids of all ages, even 81 like me."
Efrem L, Scottsdale
"A jewel! This musical is a rare delicate jewel that is so pure and sensitive and enchanting. Bravo to the incredible cast and crew AND the set designer. I was visually transported!”
Kurt R, Hilliard
"Best music, best set. Tunes you can hum when you leave the theater. Shows like that don’t come around too often. Best music musical I’ve seen in a while. Amazing set. Must be complex. Huge congratulations to the designers."
Lanning L, Honolulu

MJ Reviews

Michael Jackson's unique and unparalleled artistry sets Broadway ablaze in this 4x Tony Award-winning hit.

"Gave me goosebumps.I got Goosebumps at the beginning of the show because it was so real. It felt like Michael Jackson was really there. The story was touching and emotional. I had tears. The performances were completely believable and exciting! Loved it!"
Greg G, Tucscon
"Absolutely brilliant. As someone who attends musicals regularly and has seen Michael Jackson live when he was still with us, this musical is phenomenal. The actor who plays Michael is absolutely sensational, if you didn’t know better you would think it was him. A must see!”
Louise B, Kelvin Grove
"Inspiring and heartbreaking all in one.This show was incredible. The production value, talent, and creativity is a 10/10 must see. I took a friend who had never seen a Broadway show and he was stunned by how inspiring it was. The three versions of MJ throughout his history was really interesting to watch. Well done."
Briana S, Milton

Moulin Rouge! The Musical Reviews

Baz Luhrmann’s revolutionary film comes to life onstage, remixed in a new musical mash-up extravaganza.

"An unforgettable night!Absolutely loved every moment of Moulin Rouge! The energy was electric from start to finish. The cast delivered phenomenal performances — the singers were beyond amazing, and every note gave me chills. The song choices were so fun and creative, blending perfectly with the story. An unforgettable night filled with talent, passion, and pure entertainment!"
Rachelle R, El Paso
"Amazing. My wife and I had the pleasure of attending this performance, and we were absolutely captivated by the experience. The intricately designed sets transported us to another world, while the talented performers delivered breathtaking performances that left us in awe. Every moment was a delightful surprise!”
Anthony K, Groton
"Stunning! From the very beginning, the scene was set and we were hooked in to the sumptuous setting of the Moulin Rouge. The costumes, set and staging were incredible, the cast delivered a vibrant performance, with familiar tunes compiled together , backed up by the amazing orchestra. One of the best shows I've ever seen."
Joanna C, Ashby-De-La-Zouch

Oh, Mary! Reviews

Cole Escola's dark comedy about a miserable, suffocated Mary Todd Lincoln in the weeks leading up to Abraham Lincoln’s assassination.

"Fresh, creative and entertaining!This show was such a breath of fresh air! The cast was amazing, the writing was quick and funny. Definitely recommending it to my family and friends to see!"
Marcos F, Nashville
"An absolutely brilliant show! Oh, Mary is riotously funny and I haven’t laughed that hard in ages! Each actor somehow manages to bring out the humanity of completely unhinged characters. The humor is in-your-face bawdy, so more conservative theater goers may think twice. For the rest of us, don’t hesitate! Buy those tickets NOW!”
Tim H, Santa Clara
"Out of breath from laughing. The writing, acting, scene changes, comic timing etc. make this a must see! Non stop 80 minutes of giggles, laughter and amazement at the tight ensemble work and delivery."
Alan B, Flushing

Operation Mincemeat: A New Musical Reviews

A fast-paced, hilarious and unbelievable true story of the twisted secret mission that won us World War II.

"A small cast with BIG talent.This show was a joy to be a part of. It was a skillfully woven mixture of energy, comedy and pathos. I thought that both the set and lighting designs were absolutely fabulous. And who can possibly listen to Jak Malone singing "Dear Bill" without shedding a tear. It is an experience that will prove to be an enduring Broadway moment. Kudos to all responsible. Well done indeed."
Lauren P, New Milford
"Fantastic! I wasn’t sure what to expect but I had been told Operation Mincemeat was good. That was an understatement. First of all the story was highly enjoyable, both funny and touching at times. Secondly, the music was wonderful. And lastly the actors were incredible talented. The 5 actors changed character almost undetectably and became a totally believable new person instantly. The timing is perfect. Their voices and harmony were superb.”
Catherine C, Destin
"Operation Mincemeat is phenomenal. It has humor, drama and amazing actors! "I loved this show from the first minute to the last. It has amazing charm, humor and actual history. It is a must see!"
Carolyn W, Brooklyn

Ragtime Reviews

Ahrens and Flaherty's powerful adaptation of E.L. Doctorow's novel returns to Broadway.

"Magnificent and timely theatre! First understand that we have always loved this show-its message and the music! But this production has multiplied everything we love with stunning performances and wonderful staging. The emotional impact of the show is especially powerful right now. Thank you for this important and powerful theatre."
Kathleen F, Grosse Pointe
"Utterly breathtaking. What a perfect depiction of a very unspeakably cruel time in history with songs that will equally break your heart and stir your soul. The cast and production were perfection. Several standing ovations long before the curtain call! ”
Nancy H, Carmel
"Inspiring experience! Wonderful revival. Loved everything about this experience. When there is a standing ovation in the middle of Act 1, you know you are in for an amazing evening. Cast was so good and even the fairly sparse staging created some memorable scenes. It felt like the audience really needed this right now. Inspiring indeed!"
Melissa S, Dallas

SIX: The Musical Reviews

From Tudor Queens to Pop Icons, the SIX wives of Henry VIII take the microphone to remix five hundred years of historical heartbreak into a celebration of 21st century girl power!

"Herstory at its best! The show is as much a concert as it is a show and history, sorry, herstory lesson. It's a whirlwind 80 minutes of vocalists at the top of their game (pop music game). It is fun, vibrant, and nonstop. Their energy and enthusiasm was contagious as all get out. Although the dialogue between songs is scant, it delivers a powerful message."
Alan A, Columbia
"Amazing and clever. Just loved the show. The cast was great, each bringing their personalities to their part. The costumes were exquisite and the all female band, dynamite. I would definitely recommend this musical and see it again.”
Marilyn A, San Jose
"Total queens! Loved it from start to finish! Fabulously talented cast, amazing songs, great energy and fun throughout. One of the best I've seen."
Katie K, Wilmington

Stranger Things: The First Shadow Reviews

Visit Hawkins, Indiana before the world turned upside down in this prequel to the popular Netflix series.

"Stranger Things fans, this one's for you. The Stranger Things Broadway show is a fantastic experience for fans of the series. The acting is top-notch, the special effects are jaw-dropping, and the production captures the eerie, thrilling spirit of Hawkins perfectly. It's a must-see for anyone who loves the show. That said, if you're not already familiar with Stranger Things, it might take a little time to catch up with the plot and characters. Still, the suspense, atmosphere, and spectacle make it a thrilling night at the theater. Highly recommended for fans and thrill-seekers alike!"
Aditya V, Princeton Junction
"On the edge of my seat with Stranger Things: The First Shadow. I just saw Stranger Things: The First Shadow and it was incredible. The writing was strong and the execution seamless, keeping me on the edge of my seat from beginning to end. The suspense never let up, and the dark music added layers of drama and intensity in a way that felt almost invisible but deeply effective. I would recommend this show to anyone, whether you are a fan of science fiction theater or simply someone who appreciates a powerful story. It is thrilling, immersive, and absolutely worth experiencing.”
Guillermo I, Newark
"Mind-blowing Absolutely loved the show! The actors, the stage, the lighting, the sound effects — everything was just spot on! I'm honestly in awe of how the team pulled this off. Every character nailed their part, and it's such a perfect prequel to my favorite show. I'd totally watch it again and can't wait to tell my friends and family about it!"
Harsha R, Scarborough

The Book of Mormon Reviews

The nine-time Tony Award-winning musical, from the creators of South Park.

"Entertaining! This show is a hoot! It has you totally entertained throughout. The singing was great as was the witty dialogue delivered so well by the actors. So happy that I finally got to see it and in such a beautiful theatre on my visit to New York!"
Melinda B, Fullarton
"Amazing show! Absolutely loved it! The cast was amazing, the energy was nonstop, and the whole show just pulled me in from start to finish. The music, the lights, the vibe everything was on point. Definitely one of those Broadway shows you walk out of still smiling!"
Anabel M, Lehigh Acres
"Fantastic. What a wonderful surprise!!! My husband and I weren't expecting this and I have to say it was one of the best shows we've seen in a long time. We really loved it and laughed a lot. A big congratulations to all the actors who gave us an excellent time and I can only recommend this show which is out of the ordinary from what we are used to seeing."
Christiane Janine S, Boliqueime

The Great Gatsby Reviews

The roaring '20s take the stage in the musical adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's timeless novel.

"A great time at the theater! The performers were outstanding. The sets and costumes were sparkling and delicious. If you are looking to wring every last drop of social critique and depth of meaning out of Fitzgerald’s masterpiece you might be disappointed. However, if you want to have a glittering, toe-tapping, eye-popping frolic that stays true to what you expect from American musical theater, this is well worth a trip to New York. Even when practically everyone knows the plot already, you will enjoy the yearning and ambition of the American dream interpreted though a very talented cast and crew. And then, like me, you will enjoy return to the source and reread one of the great American novels."
Laurel J, Middlebury
"Absolutely spectacular! Seeing this show was the most anticipated part of my New York trip, and it definitely did not disappoint! It completely exceeded my expectations of what I thought it was going to be. It was extravagant, charming, and just absolutely mesmerizing! Everyone should see this show at least once. I’m considering making another trip to see it again!”
Jordan B, Valrico
"Fantastic production. So much talent on stage. I thought the story was very easy to follow and the singing and dancing was outstanding. I had just recently watched the movie and the show told the story beautifully I thought. The singing talent on this stage is simply top notch. I would come back with someone to watch again."
Robert L, Ocala

The Lion King Reviews

Pride Rock comes to glorious life in Disney's long-running hit musical.

"A wonderful voyage into imagination. The show is full of energy, color and has a great message. It is the second time I have seen the show in 20 years and I loved it just as much."
Claudio R, Carolina
"Spectacular! I was so overwhelmed by the opening it had me in tears. I felt so silly but it was just so beautiful. The entire production was flawless. I was in awe of it all.”
Jodi S, Brooklyn
"Overall amazing! The entire show was spectacular! The colors, the lighting, the costumes, the stagecraft- all top notch. The perfectly blended music and sound, together with the animated acting and singing added to the wonderful experience! It’s no wonder that the Lion King has been Broadway royalty for so many years!"
Raymond H, Exeter

The Outsiders Reviews

The Tony Award®-winning Best Musical based on S.E. Hinton's classic novel and Francis Ford Coppola's motion picture.

"Engaging and emotional. Loved the portrayal of the characters. The staging was simple but impactful. Even if you are not familiar with the book or movie it was easy to follow and you become immersed in the characters."
Amy M, Monroeville
"An electrifying gut-punch of a Broadway experience. The Outsiders absolutely blew me away. From the moment the lights went down, it pulled me straight into Tulsa and never let go. The performances are raw, authentic, and dripping with emotion. You don't just watch these characters, you feel every ounce of their pain, hope, and loyalty. The music? Absolutely phenomenal; hauntingly beautiful one moment, then heart-pounding the next. The choreography is kinetic and charged, turning fights and chases into pure stage poetry. And the set design is stunning; gritty, immersive, and so full of atmosphere it feels like you're right there on the streets with the Greasers and the Socs. By the time the curtain fell, I was speechless. It's not just a show—it's a visceral, soul-shaking experience about found family, survival, and what it means to stay gold. If you can get a ticket, run."
Nate Q, Neenah
"The music, lyrics, set and performance was perfect. The cast was fantastic but they had so much to work with too. The set was amazing and the staging was superb. The cast left it all on the stage. Raw, emotional and gut wrenching! Absolutely perfect."
Richard L, Millersville

Wicked Reviews

The Broadway sensation that looks at what happened in the Land of Oz... but from a different angle.

"Brought tears to my eyes! Truly the BEST experience for my first broadway show in my 30s. The actors were nothing short of AMAZING! The props, the music, the vocals, the COSTUMES were everything! The lead actresses played their parts so well, it was hard to even imagine them outside of those characters because you become immersed in what they show you! 10/10 brining my kids to see this next time!"
Heather H, Houma
"Wicked blew me away. I genuinely felt like a kid experiencing Christmas for the first time – wide-eyed, amazed, completely swept up in the magic. The emotions, the visual effects, the vocal and acting talent – everything was absolutely flawless. One of those rare shows that makes you forget the world outside the theater."
Sebastian B, Poznan
"Do NOT miss this show! If I won the lottery, I would come to this play everyday!! The music was spectacular, the performances were stellar and the production was flawless! Cannot recommend strongly enough!"
Susan E G, Groveland

Review Roundup: Fan Reviews for the Best Broadway Shows in NYC

Broadway Newsletters