"It’s nice to see an original story (and a true one). The staging is ingenious and entertaining, and most of the five actors are personable, in effective gender-blind casting among many roles. The songs are not in any cohesive flavor. There’s an anachronistic Act II opener that can’t justify itself because (as is often the case, especially in the first act) the lyrics are practically impossible to understand. Only one song is a knockout, with a powerful but restrained emotional punch. Oddly, this emotion is not lavished directly upon the historical figure who most deserves it; he is honored almost as a postscript."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 9, 2026
The lyrics need to be slowed down ...
"The acting was very good. But most of the songs were sung at the speed of light. I grew up in England and even I could not understand most of what they were singing. Speed can be fun...once. Also, several of the songs were sung with one character singing different lyrics than another at the same time, and then another, and yet another. This works once, maybe. It happened far too often in this show. Also, for the first half of the show, most of the mics were too low and were drowned out by the orchestra.They fixed the mics for the 2nd half."
...
Read more
Karen T from Pasadena on Oct 7, 2026
Tough to follow
"Good acting, good singing. We could not understand/follow the story."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 17, 2026
Hard to understand the lyrics.
" We were a group of five adults. Age of 24 to 61. We were in the upper balcony. We could not understand the lyrics to the songs for most of the show. A few of the quieter slower songs you could hear. Otherwise, the instruments were so loud that you could not understand the lyrics. The characters were singing. Since it’s a musical with limited dialogue, the lyrics are what tell you the plot. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 7, 2026
Excellent music and acting but a subpar story
"If you love musicals, great singing and acting the most in a performance, then enjoy. I like musicals with a powerful story as well (Hamilton, Hadestown, Rent, Mormon, etc). The premise was interesting the story delivery was not."
...
Read more
Peter C from Sherman Oaks on Aug 1, 2026
Interesting story, but tough to grasp the lyrics
"A lively set of songs and great acting and choreography, but my wife and I both had trouble understanding any of the lyrics, whether due to the accents, the rapid rhythm, or our age we aren't sure. But we noticed that not too many in the audience seemed to be able to appreciate all the lyrics either."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jul 18, 2026
Decent show
"Production value was great. Only 5 actors for entire play + it's a comedy. I enjoy more emotional/dramatic Broadways such as Dear Evan Hansen, Wicked, Aladdin, etc. Didn't enjoy this much due to that + found the songs and singing to be average for Broadway level."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 17, 2026
Ambitious but Flawed
"Bravura performances by all five cast members and the orchestra. But the overly quirky mannerisms and broad brush characterizations took away from the message and meaning of the story."
...
Read more
David D from Pownal on Apr 15, 2026
Didn't live up to potential
"We were seated near the back of the theater and had great difficulty understanding the lyrics. sometimes, it seemed the ators weren't seaking into the microphone at all. Being soft-spoken just does't work. People near the front laughed at some jokes that we just weren't able to hear. It really interfered with our enjoyment of the show. We could understand them better during the second act."
...
Read more
Kathryn T from Monroe Twp. on Mar 23, 2026
Fast moving, incredibly hard to understand.
"It could be a five star, but could not understand the actors. Guess I need closed captioning. Frustrating to go through the whole play and only understand 10%. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 25, 2026
Meh
"This musical was really well directed, well acted, and the set design was excellent. But at the end of the day, it's just not great. It's not gonna be a classic. The songs aren't catchy, the story not that engaging, lots of strange tangents and plot decisions, etc. All and all a really well done production of a mediocre musical. Sorry to be the barer of bad news. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 8, 2026
Not for Everyone
"The staging, lighting and performances are first-rate. My problem is, having read the book, I don’t think this is subject-matter for a musical comedy. I can’t put my finger on what “British humor” is, but it’s on full display here, and it just isn’t funny, at least to me. The characters are caricatures, clowning through what in real life was deadly serious. "
...
Read more
John W from Mill Valley on Oct 8, 2025
Know the story before you attend
"Unless one is familiar with the book or movies, it would have been difficult to follow. It was very entertaining and the musical numbers were great, but having only 5 cast members also made it confusing as to who-was-who, at least for the first few acts."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 6, 2025
Not what I expected
"I was expecting it to be more humorous … based on reviews and Tony award. I was disappointed as it was way too long with parts that were not needed. At times I found myself completely bored and wanting to leave the theatre. It was not what I hoped. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 3, 2025
Depends on your funny bone
"If you love a farce this one’s for you. The silliness was well executed, just not my cup of humor. Many audience members were in stitches over the gags."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 15, 2025
Hard to hear…
"If you do go, set your expectations low. It ends better than it starts…it builds and gets better as it goes on. The actors are very hard to understand especially when they are all singing at the same time. They would all benefit from better annunciation."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 31, 2025
Disappointing show
"The english accents made the dialogue hard to understand. I also am not a fan of British humor. Its a bit too slap stick and corny for my taste. But the couple next to me seemed to enjoy it"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 6, 2025
Actually mincemeat
"Not particularly funny or clever as ads would lead you to believe. Actors were impressive in their quick changes but the story is bland, veering from attempted comedy to melodrama.
A miss. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 24, 2025
Brilliant but couldn’t understand the voices
"This play has brilliant choreography, amazing costume changes, magical set design and lots of energy. However, I COULD NOT UNDERSTAND WHAT ANY OF THE CAST WERE SAYING!!! I thought it was me. but I spoke with two other couples and they had the same difficult time distinguishing the words. "
...
Read more
Richard W from UTICA on Nov 15, 2026
Interesting but difficult to understand
"The show was clever and interesting but very difficult to understand. With their English accent and rapid speech we missed about 50% of the dialogue."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 26, 2026
I couldn’t understand a word of it
"Between the average quality mic/ sound system, the accents, the rapid fire sung dialogue I left at intermission because except for hearing a few random words I had not a clue what was going on in this show. Here’s what I got, a dead body, something about hitler and the guy everyone dissed (Charlie) had a plan. A casket. It’s the 4th show I’ve seen this week and the only one I left because I couldn’t make out what was even going on. I sit in the first 7 rows typically to be close to the stage and to the sound equipment. I use assistive devices occasionally, which were of no use in this case.
The cast was smart and I am sure with a better audio system I would have enjoyed this theater."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 31, 2026
Mixed
"The cast of five were all talented, no question. A monumental effort to play so many characters so smoothly. Stage craft was great. Our seats were in the rear mezzanine with a great view of the stage yet both of us (no hearing loss on our part) had difficulty deciphering the lyrics. However, the prime reason for giving it only 2 stars - we found the gender switching of 3 of the main characters (female actors playing male roles and a male actor playing a female character) to be a distraction and did not serve the purpose of telling the story, talented though they were."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 21, 2026
Tried to like it
"Never added up to an enjoyable musical. All five actors were good - two were very good. All were working hard to entertain. Certainly didn’t leave the theater humming any songs. To turn a line from the movie Amadeus: too many words. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 31, 2026
Disappointing
"I’ve seen so many Tony award winning musicals on Broadway and this one did not measure up to the others. The dialogue and lyrics were hard to understand. The music not memorable. There was really nothing outstanding to mention. "
...
Read more
Melissa M from Spring on May 21, 2026
Read the whole story before you go.
"The music was very loud, and it was hard to hear the accent with the accompaniment.
The audiences' members were laughing before we could even try to hear the words. For people who were there for the first time it was hard to get all the words."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on May 7, 2026
Viewing 1-25 of 29
About
Operation Mincemeat: A New Musical
The year is 1943 and right now we’re losing the war. Luckily, we’re about to gamble all our futures on a stolen corpse.
Singin’ in the Rain meets Strangers on a Train, Operation Mincemeat is the fast-paced, hilarious and unbelievable true story of the twisted secret mission that won us World War II.
Bursting at the seams with the kind of chaos you couldn’t invent, the question is: how did a dead body, a fake love letter, and - of all people - Ian Fleming come together to wrong-foot Hitler?